Wave and Wind are the New Hybrid Renewable Energy Source

News and Insights RSS

By Laurent Albert, CEO, Seabased

The ability to combine the power of wave and wind to stabilize energy flow to the electric grid is one of the most exciting opportunities I’ve seen since I started with marine renewable technologies, because it has the potential to be a game changer.

It goes a long way toward solving the electricity grid’s need for a stable power supply and it's a double win for offshore wind developers, because elevating the baseload supplied to the grid lowers the risk of the power park.

Recent events in places like Japan and the UK, and related studies, suggest that the stability of today’s power grids is compromised when the energy supply fluctuates beyond a certain threshold (10-30%). It results in grid failure and a costly re-start process. This variability challenge will be a major factor in the planning and architecture of the renewable energy supply in the years to come.

People want their countries and communities to hit the ambitious targets they’ve set for renewable energy, but not at the risk of blackouts. Many resources  have to be harnessed to help reach goals of 80-100% renewables, including battery storage and smart grid technology. Because they naturally peak at different times, coupling wave and wind can go a long way toward solving these challenges.

The time is now

The timing to capitalize on synergies between wave energy and offshore wind is auspicious. In 2019, a record 6.1 GW of new offshore wind capacity was installed. That brought more clean power to the grid, but also a challenge to make that variable power work with relatively stable grid demand. Adding wave power is a natural step because it creates more stability.

For industry experts, this fact alone is not a revelation, as the balancing act performed by wind and wave has garnered interest and study for at least a decade. However, due to the lack of a viable wave energy technology, it has merely been theory up to this point.

What is new for 2020 is that after years of research, experimentation, and work by scientists, engineers, entrepreneurs, and investors, the wave energy industry has reached a stage of development where pairing wave and wind is now a practical reality that can make life easier for grid operators on nearly every coast. As an engineer who has been working in marine renewables for the better part of a decade, I feel fortunate to be a part of this phase of wave energy’s evolution.

The challenge of variability

The supply of energy from many renewable sources is, by nature, quite variable. For many purposes, it’s handy that the sun sets at night and rises in the morning. However, this poses an issue for the grid.

Electricity grids are designed to work with a consistent flow of power that can meet the daily minimum demand—baseload--and also adjust to changes in demand. But it can be difficult to predict, days in advance, how much power a grid will be able to get from variable sources.

Though the world has doubled the installed capacity of renewables since 2009, reaching an impressive 2,500 GW in 2019, even the most advanced countries still only consistently derive around 30% of their power from renewables. Balancing renewables with renewables is a highly effective way to increase this penetration. 

The game changer: wave and wind combined

Waves are highly predictable, completely renewable, and while they are not exactly available on demand - you can’t turn them on and off at will - waves work 24/7, 365. They are accessible to the 80% of the world’s largest cities, which are in coastal areas. Moreover, they surround islands, a huge number of which currently rely on expensive and polluting imported fossil fuels. So, wave energy can be an accessible, renewable, CO2-free power source, for hundreds of millions of people. It’s an immense resource: the estimated theoretical global output of wave power is 29,500 TWh/yr—roughly 125% of the current global demand for electricity.

Pairing ocean wave energy with offshore wind can be a game changer for renewable energy.

To illustrate the synergies between these two renewables, our team at Seabased studied the case of Galway Bay in Ireland. Historical data from wind and wave conditions shows how combining wave and wind could more than double the baseload available to the grid from a single ocean power facility.

Our study assumed both wind and wave were providing equal amounts of energy to the grid for two weeks in April that included no extreme weather. We paired wind data from the Photovoltaic Geographical Information System and wave data from Ifremer. The result is a rough approximation of the power that would have been generated over the period.

The data shows that though some days the wind could produce a lot of power, the baseload, or consistent power produced by the wind every day during this period, is pretty small.

Wave energy also has peaks and valleys, but they’re less dramatic during this period. The baseload is much larger.

Even more importantly, wave and wind peak at different times. If you look at the image below, which transposes the previous two, you can see that wave peaks when wind wanes, and vice versa. This gift of mother nature - the natural difference in timing of peaks and valleys - makes the combination very interesting for the grid.

While wave and wind provide different levels of power at different times, they are both providing some power all the time. In an ocean plant that combined wave and wind, the amount of electricity generated would be the sum of the two. If you stack the graphs to calculate how much power wind and wave would produce at the same time, you see that their alternating peaks and valleys mean that the combined baseload they provide, is greater than the sum of the two separate baseloads. 

For these two weeks, the baseload would be 15MW. This is greater than the sum of 8MW for wave and 3MW for wind. The synergies of the peaks in production for each of the renewable sources is what makes this possible.

Other studies showed similar results.

Additional efficiencies may also be possible if offshore wind farms and wave energy parks are co-located. Some of the most expensive elements of offshore power include marine substations and subsea cables leading to the grid connection point. Costs for these and other supplies and labor can be shared. Moreover, if the two power sources were able to use the same ocean real estate to create more power, that would mean less of a demand on space in coastal waters, which must also accommodate other activities like fishing, tourism, and shipping.

The first known patent on wave energy was filed in 1799 by Pierre-Simon Girard, another French engineer, who saw the potential in the constant rolling of the waves toward the shore. It is thrilling to be in a position, 220 years later, to work with others in the renewable industry to use nature’s symbiosis to create clean energy that protects our planet.

Can a wave energy park work as an artificial reef?

News and Insights RSS

Artificial reefs are objects introduced into the ocean to provide a habitat for sea creatures. From sunken ships to old buses, scientists have repurposed numerous types of hard surfaces dropped to the sea floor to provide habitat and increase biodiversity. Where previously only burrowing creatures could live, the introduction of an artificial reef creates an instant city that attracts fish, crustaceans, mollusks, and others that prefer hard-walled homes. Such biodiversity is essential for ocean health. Some artificial reefs are beautiful to begin with, like the gallery of statues called Silent Evolution off the coast of Cancun; others begin as junk and are made beautiful by the life that grows on and around them, and by the patinas the saltwater gives them over time. And some artificial reefs can start their lives as wave energy parks.

The question of whether marine energy installations could serve as artificial reefs has been studied for years. Several of those studies have been done in collaboration with Seabased, with wave energy parks built off the Swedish coast. In these parks near Sotenäs and Lysekil, gravity based linear generators - somewhat resembling large spark plugs with concrete bases - were installed at a depth of 25 or 50 meters. While folks at the surface celebrated the world’s first multi-generator grid-connected wave parks, scientists watched and took measurements to see what the environmental impact would be.

Coastal areas are often surrounded by barren sea floors of sand, clay, silt, or rock. The first three of these provide a stable base for Seabased’s wave energy converter (WEC) generators. They’re placed on the sea bottom and connected, with steel cables, to large buoys that sit on the surface, bobbing with the waves, creating motion in the generator on the seabed. This motion is vertical, without blades or turbines that could catch animals. From the generators, power is channeled to a marine substation which converts it into the proper electric voltage, sends it to a connection hub through subsea cable, and then the electricity travels to a grid connection point.

Artist rendering of early Seabased wave energy park

 

UNDERWATER CITY FOR SEA CREATURES

The bases themselves are built of concrete, and it’s these concrete bases that scientists have experimented with. In one of the wave parks, scientists made holes of various sizes at different heights around the edges of the base creating a housing development, per se, for fish, crabs, and other creatures that feel more secure living in a structure than under the sand. But once the wave parks are installed, with or without the bases with holes, it doesn’t really take long to get the neighbors interested. 

“Whether they’re intentionally placed or arrive there by accident, artificial reefs usually settle quite quickly,” said Anke Bender, a PhD candidate in the department of Electrical Engineering at Uppsala University in Sweden who has been studying the artificial reef development around Seabased’s generators at Sotenäs for years. The ecological impact of the generators is her dissertation topic, which is planned for release at the end of 2020. Within a few weeks of a reef structure appearing, she says, sea animals discover the new real estate and start to move in. 

Together with her professor, Jan Sundberg, who has a PhD in evolutionary theory, Bender and other scientists have tracked which species grew more abundant around the wave park and how they interacted with it. They were especially interested in how sea life that has commercial value responded. Since the loss of fishing area can be one of the objections that arise with wave installations, they wanted to see if the wave park itself could become a better habitat and breeding or spawning area than the seabed. Hopefully, it would actually increase desirable populations and therefore, ultimately, help fishermen. They discovered that it could. Several species of fish and crabs had made the bases their home. Brown crabs found it especially appealing, and their numbers increased by more than 50%. But most exciting was the growth of the populations of Norway lobsters, which—in Lysekil—seemed to like burrowing under the edges of the generators.  Also known as Dublin Bay prawn, langoustine or langostino, and scampi, these are Europe’s most important commercial crustacean. Once they settle into an area as juveniles, they stay there. So barring an event or fishing, their populations would increase.  One year after the installation of the wave park, the lobsters had settled in and were twice as abundant inside the wave park as in the control area. By the second year after installation, the number of all Norway lobsters in the area had nearly doubled. In that year, the numbers outside the park became roughly the same as those inside it. In theory, the population growing in the park, protected from trawling and other fishing methods, could feed into a larger population in surrounding fishing areas.

Many other promising studies have been done using the wave parks, several by Olivia Langhamer, PhD, Analyst at the Unit Environmental Implementations and Enforcement at Swedish Agency for Marine and Water Management. Working with colleagues, she has studied Seabased generator bases placed 25 meters deep at two locations near Lysekil, on the Swedish west coast. The studies included observations of sea life abundance, the effectiveness of the holes in increasing biodiversity, and the impact on populations that may be displaced by the generators. Some of the results of those studies indicated that populations of sea life increased months after the generators were deployed at one location, and fish and crabs were significantly more abundant on the foundations than in the surrounding soft bottoms. Three types of fish were observed using the holes, two of them cod. But many were seen around the foundations.  Eight species of fish were recorded on the foundations, while only three species were noted in the control areas outside the wave park, indicating, perhaps, that the parks may contribute to biodiversity.

The scientists learned that each park ecosystem must be treated as unique to provide maximum benefit to the environment. “It’s really an exciting opportunity”, says Laurent Albert, CEO of Seabased. “Just as different birdhouses attract different birds, we look forward to working closely with scientists to tailor our wave energy parks to attract different species of marine life. The goal for Seabased is that each artificial reef will encourage a balanced ecosystem that is healthy both for the ocean and for desirable commercial species in exactly that area.” 

THERE GOES THE NEIGHBORHOOD

The risk of increasing biodiversity is that you might attract species that don’t really belong in the area and that could mess up the ecosystem. As Bender noted, any time you introduce something new into an ecosystem, you can create problems. For example, the existence of the wave park seemed to possibly reduce the number of spiny starfish—perhaps because of an increased number of predators. While the bases provide habitat for some creatures, they also take up space that other species might have wanted to burrow into. They provide shelter for some species, but might interrupt the normal migration patterns (although not by much) of others. And then there are invasive species: species that wouldn’t have naturally lived in the area when it was just a sandy flat now find the place attractive. Species that are picked up to ballast a ship in one place are dropped off again in another, or carried in by tides and storms, and they can find the new housing development to their liking. Predators treat the environment like a new restaurant. All of this can be advantageous or challenging, depending on how it affects the balance of the ecosystem. 

As of 2020, however, researchers at the Seabased installations did not find any invasive species. 

CREATING A SAFE HAVEN

 The other risks that come with putting a power installation into a natural environment include man-made ones. Using pile drivers to anchor the generators disturbs the ecosystem during construction; using toxic oils or paints or materials pollutes the water; having moving parts threatens wildlife; electromagnetism might impact the environment; and finally, there’s the noise of the generators hard at work. Fortunately, Seabased’s wave energy parks that can serve as artificial reefs have little or none of these problems.

We just rest the generators on the sea floor without pile drivers. The generators don’t use oil and the paints used have been proven non-toxic in saltwater. There are no turbines or blades. The electromagnetic impact is slight, it extends only a meter from the subsea transmission cables. And while there is some noise, researchers have observed that the creatures don’t seem to even notice it. 

The ocean is not one ecosystem. Around the world, each wave environment is unique, as are the communities around them. And any wave energy installation must work within local constraints and maximize local opportunities for creating clean energy, economic opportunities, jobs, and more. In the same way, each ocean ecosystem must be understood and helped to thrive and flourish with understanding and appreciation for its unique flora and fauna. And we’ll continue to explore ways to do that. Helping to protect the earth is part of our mission.